Web Design Agency or Freelancer? Pros & Cons

When it comes to web design, business owners can choose between working with a web design agency or hiring a freelancer.

This article will examine the advantages and disadvantages of both web design agencies and freelancers, allowing you to make an informed choice based on your specific requirements and financial resources.

How to Decide Between Web Design Agencies and Freelance Designers

Size of Business

Hiring a freelance designer can be a cost-effective solution if you have a small business or startup. As a single person, freelance web designers often have lower overhead costs and can offer competitive rates, making them a good option for businesses on a budget. They can also provide a more personalised and flexible approach to your project, as they often work on a one-to-one basis with clients. 

The benefit of hiring a web design agency for a small business you gain an entire team who can work faster on your website, a quicker turn around may lead to gaining more online business faster than a freelancer. They can also help provide advise on both web design and how to go about marketing yourself online afterwards. 

If you have a larger business with more complex design needs it's advisable to consider working with a website design agency in NZ. Agencies often have a larger team of designers and developers, allowing them to tackle more extensive projects and provide a wider range of services. They may also have a more established reputation and a portfolio of successful projects, which can be reassuring for larger businesses.

Scale of Project

The scale of your project is another critical factor to take into account when deciding between a web design agency and a freelance designer. If you have a relatively simple project, such as a basic website redesign, a freelance designer may be more than capable of handling the job. 

However, suppose you have a larger, more complex project, such as an e-commerce website or multi-page website and SEO migration. In that case, a web design agency may be a better option. Agencies often have more experience working on complex projects and have a larger team of designers, developers, and project managers to handle every aspect of your project. This can help ensure a more streamlined and efficient process with fewer delays or issues.

Timeline

Your timeline is another important consideration when deciding between a web design agency and a freelance designer. If you have a tight deadline, you need to understand how much time each can dedicate to your project.

You might be in luck if you can find a dedicated full-time freelance designer who can work more flexibly around your schedule and provide quick turnaround times. Whereas many of them use their skills as a way to make extra money outside of their day job so fast turnarounds may be difficult unless they are able to work solidly after-hours. 

Agencies typically have a more structured process in place, with a project manager overseeing every aspect of your project. This can help ensure your project stays on track, even if unexpected delays arise. Additionally, agencies often have a larger team of designers and developers, which can help speed up the development process and ensure your project is completed on time. There is less risk of delays if designers or developers get sick as they will be able to spread the work between their team. 

Is it Better to be a Freelancer or an Agency?

When looking at who to choose you can consider who to choose based on the expertise, the level of communication you need for your web design project. The below pros and cons are points to evaluate when you are building a new website.

Expertise & Resources

Pros and Cons of A Professional Web Design Agency

Pros

• Specialisation: Web design agencies often have a specialised team of designers, developers, and project managers have specialized skills in their respective fields. This means you'll have access to a wide range of skills and expertise, which can be especially beneficial for complex projects.
• Large Team of Experts : Web design agencies have more hands on deck to work on your project. You gain a graphic designer, a web designer, a UX/UI specialist, a web developers, SEO experts and digital marketing Christchurch specialists all in one team. This can help ensure that the project is completed within the desired timeline and that it's up to the highest quality standards.
• Better resources: A web design agency often has better resources at its disposal than a freelancer. This can include access to the latest software, hardware, and design tools, which can help create a more polished and professional end product.
• Accountability: An agency has a reputation to uphold and a team to manage, which means that they are often more accountable for their work than a freelancer. They are more likely to provide reliable timelines, deliverables, and results and offer ongoing support to ensure the project's success.

Cons

• Higher Cost: One of the main drawbacks of working with a web design agency is that it can be more expensive than hiring a freelancer. Agencies often have higher overhead costs and need to pay their team members, which can lead to higher project fees.
• Less Personalization: While agencies can offer a specialised team, they are often busier meaning you may not have a close working relationship with your designers compared to a freelancer.
• Communication Hurdles: With a larger team, there can be more potential for communication hurdles or misunderstandings. This can lead to delays or revisions, which can impact the overall timeline and cost of the project.
• Limited Flexibility: Web design agencies often have set processes and workflows that can limit flexibility in terms of changes or revisions to the project. Choosing the wrong agency may end up challenging for clients with specific ideas or requests.

That's where Do Good Things is different compared to more ridged web design agencies. We are a small agile digital agency who work one on one with our clients.

Our professional web designers, SEO experts and digital marketing eads work together behind the scenes to deliver you a personalised website at an affordable price. We are always up for a chat about your business and how we can help so get in touch for your free consultation

Whether you're just starting out or looking to take your online visibility to the next level, we can help. So if you're asking yourself, "what do web design agencies do?" get in touch with us, and we'll happily answer your questions.

‍

What are the Pros and Cons of Freelance Web Developers?

Pros

• Cost-effective: One of the biggest advantages of working with a freelancer is that they often charge less than web design agencies. Freelancers typically have lower overhead costs and may not need to pay salaries to other team members, which can make them a more affordable option for smaller businesses or projects with tight budgets.
• Personalised Attention: Working with a freelancer can offer more personalised attention, as they can often focus solely on your project without the distractions of other clients. This can help build a closer working relationship and ensure that your specific needs and preferences are taken into account throughout the project.
• Flexibility: Freelancers are often more flexible than web design agencies when it comes to making changes or revisions to the project. They can adapt to your needs and offer more individualised solutions to any problems arising during the design process.
• Direct Communication: Freelancers are often easier to communicate with than larger agencies, as they typically have a more direct line of communication. This can make it easier to get updates on the project, discuss any concerns or questions, and ensure that your feedback is heard and incorporated into the final product.

Cons

• Limited Availability: Freelancers often have limited availability, as they may juggle multiple clients or a full time job simultaneously. This can lead to longer wait times or delays in getting started on your project, which can be frustrating if you have a tight deadline.
• Limited Skillset: Freelancers may have a limited skillset compared to digital agencies, which can impact the quality or complexity of the final product. They may not have access to the same resources or team members as larger agencies, which can limit their ability to create more advanced or intricate designs.
• Dependability: While many freelancers are highly dependable and reliable, some may not be as committed to delivering high-quality work or meeting deadlines. This can be especially true if they are working on multiple projects at once or do not have a strong sense of accountability.
• Limited Support: Freelancers may not be able to offer ongoing support or maintenance after the project is completed. This can be a concern if you need help with updates or troubleshooting after launching the website.

Communication and Collaboration

Pros and Cons of Agency Communication

Pros

• Access to a Team: Web design agencies often have a team of professionals working on your project, including designers, developers, project managers, and account managers. This can make getting the support and expertise you need easier and help ensure that every aspect of the project is being considered and executed properly.
• Clear Expectations: Agencies often have a defined process for communication, which can help ensure that expectations are clear and everyone is on the same page. This can include regular check-ins, progress updates, and specific timelines or milestones.
• Consistency: Agencies often have a set standard for communication, which can help ensure that messages are consistent and clear. This can be especially helpful if you are working with multiple team members or have a complex project requiring careful coordination.
• Accountability: Agencies typically have a higher level of accountability than individual freelancers, as they have a reputation to maintain and are often more invested in ensuring client satisfaction. This can help ensure that communication is prompt and effective and that any issues or concerns are addressed promptly.

Cons

• More Formal Communication: Working with an agency can sometimes feel more formal or less personal than working with a freelancer. This can make it harder to build a close working relationship or to feel like you have a direct line of communication with the team.
• Delayed Response Time: While agencies typically have a defined process for communication, this can sometimes lead to delays in response time. For example, if you need to speak with a team member who is unavailable or if there are delays in getting feedback from other stakeholders.
• Less Flexibility: Agencies often have more rigid communication protocols, which can make it harder to make changes or adjustments on the fly. This can be frustrating if you need to pivot or adjust your approach based on new information or feedback.
• Lack of Personalization: Agencies may not be able to offer the same level of personalization or attention to detail as a freelancer. This can be especially true if you are working with a large agency with many clients, as they may not be able to give your project the same level of individualised attention as a smaller freelancer.

Pros and Cons of Freelancer Communication

Pros

• Personalised Communication: Working with a freelancer can be more personal than working with an agency. Freelancers tend to have a closer relationship with their clients, which can result in a more personalised approach to communication. This can be especially helpful if you prefer a more informal or collaborative working relationship.
• Direct Communication: Freelancers usually have a direct line of communication with their clients, which means that you can communicate with them directly without going through intermediaries. This can lead to more efficient communication and faster response times.
• Flexibility: Freelancers tend to be more flexible in terms of communication, as they do not have the same rigid communication protocols as agencies. This can be especially helpful if you need to make changes or adjustments on the fly or have a complex project requiring frequent updates.

Cons

• Availability: Freelancers often have limited availability, which can make it harder to get in touch with them or schedule meetings. This can be especially true if they are working on multiple projects at the same time.
• Lack of Consistency: Freelancers may not have a consistent process for communication, which can lead to confusion or misunderstandings. This can be especially true if you are working with a freelancer for the first time or if they are working with multiple clients simultaneously.
• Accountability: Freelancers may not have the same level of accountability as agencies, as they may not have a reputation to maintain or the same level of investment in ensuring client satisfaction. This can lead to slower response times or a lack of follow-through on commitments.

‍

Cost and Budget

Web Design Agency Versus Freelancer: How Much Do They Cost?

The cost of web design services can vary widely between web design agencies and freelancers, depending on a number of factors, including the level of experience, expertise, location, and scope of the project.

Here is a breakdown of the typical pricing for web design services offered by web design agencies and freelancers:

Web Design Agency Pricing

• Custom Web Design: Custom web design services from an agency can cost anywhere from $3,000 to $50,000 or more, depending on the complexity of the project and the agency's level of expertise.
• Template-Based Design: Template-based design services from an agency can cost anywhere from $1,000 to $10,000 or more, depending on the complexity of the project and the agency's level of expertise.
• Website Maintenance and Updates: Website maintenance and update services from an agency typically cost around $75 to $200 per hour, depending on the agency's level of expertise.
• Digital Marketing Services: Digital marketing services such as search engine optimization (SEO Wellington) and social media marketing from an agency typically cost anywhere from $1,000 to $10,000 or more per month, depending on the complexity of the project and the agency's level of expertise.

Feel free to read our complete guide if you want to know more about how much a website design costs.

Freelancer Pricing

• Custom Web Design: Custom web design services from a freelancer can cost from $1,000 to $10,000 or more, depending on the complexity of the project and the freelancer's level of expertise.
• Template-Based Design: Template-based design services from a freelancer can cost anywhere from $500 to $5,000 or more, depending on the complexity of the project and the freelancer's level of expertise.
• Website Maintenance and Updates: Website maintenance and update services from a freelancer typically cost around $50 to $150 per hour, depending on the freelancer's level of expertise.
• Digital Marketing Services: Digital marketing services such as search engine optimization (SEO) and social media marketing from a freelancer typically cost anywhere from $500 to $5,000 or more per month, depending on the complexity of the project and the freelancer's level of expertise.

It's important to keep in mind that these are just general pricing ranges, and the actual cost for your project may vary depending on your specific requirements and the skill level of the designer or agency you choose to work with. It's always a good idea to get quotes from multiple providers and compare their services and pricing before making a final decision.

Pros and Cons of Agency Costs

Pros

• Fixed Price: Web design agencies typically provide fixed price quotes for their services, which means that you know upfront how much the project will cost. This can help you budget and plan accordingly.
• Scalability: Agencies have more resources and staff than freelancers, which means that they can handle larger and more complex projects. This scalability can be helpful if you have a large project or need to complete the project quickly.
• Professionalism: Web design agencies have a professional reputation to maintain, which means they are likely to be more reliable and accountable than freelancers. They also typically have more established processes and procedures, which can lead to a smoother project experience.
• Additional Services: Web design agencies often offer additional services, such as branding, digital marketing, and SEO, which can be valuable if you need a full-service agency that can handle all aspects of your online presence.

Cons

• Higher Costs: Working with a web design agency can be more expensive than working with a freelancer, as agencies have more overhead costs, such as office rent and staff salaries. This can make it harder to stay within a tight budget.
• Less Flexibility: Web design agencies often have more rigid processes and procedures, which can limit their ability to be flexible or make changes quickly. This can be especially true if you need to make changes mid-project.
• Risk of Overbilling: Some web design agencies may over-bill clients for additional services or scope creep, leading to unexpected costs and budget overruns. Choosing an agency with a transparent pricing model who charges by project rather than hour is important to avoid these issues.

Pros and Cons of Freelancer Costs

Pros

• Lower Costs: One of the biggest perks of working with a freelance web designer is the lower cost. Freelancers typically have lower overhead costs and are able to charge less than a full-service web design agency.
• Flexibility: Freelancers are more flexible with their pricing, allowing you to negotiate a fee that fits within your budget. They may also be willing to work on a project-by-project basis or hourly rate, which can help you stay within your budget.
• Easy to Find: There are many platforms available where you can easily find and hire freelance web designers, making it easy to find someone who meets your requirements and budget.

Cons

• Limited Resources: Freelancers typically have fewer resources than a web design agency, which can limit their ability to handle larger or more complex projects. They may also have limited availability, which can cause delays in completing your project.
• Lack of Additional Services: Freelancers may not be able to offer additional services like branding, digital marketing, or SEO, which can be important for a comprehensive online presence.
• Hidden Costs: Some freelancers may charge hidden costs or unexpected fees for additional services or scope creep. It's important to have clear and transparent pricing discussions with your freelancer to avoid any unexpected costs.

If you're looking to create or redesign your website, Do Good Things good balance of one on one care with web design agency capabilities to help you achieve your online marketing goals.

We are a full service digital marketing agency that specialises in providing you with customer-focused marketing services, from website design to content optimization, search engine optimisation and performance marketing.

With our design, development, and digital marketing expertise, we can help you create a website that looks great, functions smoothly, and grows your business online. Get in touch with us now!

‍